The Diaper-Free Baby: The Natural Toilet Training Alternative For A Happier, Healthier Baby Or Toddler (2007)

By Christine Gross-Loh – 30 Q&As – Unbekoming Book Summary

In The Diaper Free Baby, Christine Gross-Loh introduces Elimination Communication (EC) as a gentle, responsive method for managing a baby’s elimination needs from birth. Unlike conventional toilet training, which typically begins around age two or three and focuses on unteaching diaper dependency, EC preserves the innate bodily awareness with which babies are born. This approach emphasizes communication over training, enabling parents to recognize and respond to their baby’s natural signals and timing patterns. However, in Western societies, the diaper industry’s financial interests subtly encourage delayed toilet training. As I explored in Diapers - Lies are Unbekoming, the prolonged use of diapers generates massive profits, creating a system that nudges parents to postpone the transition to toilet independence.

EC is not a novel concept; it is deeply rooted in cultural practices across Africa, Asia, and South America, where babies often achieve toilet independence by their first birthday. These traditions contrast sharply with Western norms, where diaper use frequently extends into toddlerhood. Beyond the environmental benefits—such as reducing the 22 billion disposable diapers discarded annually in the U.S.—and the financial savings, EC fosters a profound parent-child bond through attuned communication. By weaving insights from Gross-Loh’s work with a critique of Western diaper dependency, this introduction invites readers to explore the comprehensive summary of The Diaper Free Baby and reconsider conventional approaches to infant care.

With thanks to Christine Gross-Loh.

The Diaper-Free Baby: The Natural Toilet Training Alternative: Gross-Loh, Christine

---

Question 12: What was Christine Gross-Loh's experience with infant pottying, both in Japan and with her own children, and how did it change her perspective on potty training?

Christine Gross-Loh first encountered infant pottying while living with a host family in Japan. She observed her host family's grandmother holding her three-month-old twin granddaughters over the toilet and making a sound to cue them to eliminate. Initially, Christine felt uncomfortable with this practice, believing it to be coercive or potentially harmful. However, after having children of her own and discovering that infant pottying was common in many cultures worldwide, she decided to try it herself. When her son successfully used the potty at a young age, Christine realized that he had been eager for an alternative to soiling his diapers and that the practice enhanced his sense of well-being and comfort. This experience changed her perspective on potty training and led her to become an advocate for infant pottying.

Diapers - Lies are Unbekoming

---

Deep Dive Conversation Library (Bonus for Paid Subscribers Only)

This deep dive is based on the book:

Discussion No.69:

23 thoughts, insights and reflections from “The Diaper-Free Baby”

Thank you for your support.

Analogy

Elimination Communication is like learning to dance with a partner who doesn't speak your language. At first, you might step on each other's toes as you learn to interpret subtle body language, timing, and non-verbal cues. You watch closely for the slight shift in weight or change in posture that signals your partner is about to move in a new direction.

With practice, you develop an intuitive connection where you can anticipate your partner's movements before they happen. Sometimes you lead, sometimes you follow, but the dance becomes increasingly harmonious with fewer missteps. You don't need constant perfection—occasional missteps are just part of the learning process. What matters is the growing synchronicity between you.

Others watching might think you're doing something complicated or difficult, but for you, it becomes natural and even joyful. You're not training your partner to dance your way, nor are they training you—you're simply learning to communicate through movement. Over time, the dance becomes so fluid that onlookers can't tell who's leading and who's following. This is the essence of Elimination Communication: not a training method, but a dance of mutual awareness that allows both parent and baby to move through life more harmoniously together.

---

12-point summary

1. EC is communication, not training. Elimination Communication is a gentle approach to addressing a baby's bathroom needs from birth onward by responding to their natural signals and timing patterns rather than relying exclusively on diapers. It's about maintaining the bodily awareness babies are born with, not training them to use the toilet early. The focus is on the communication journey, not the end result.

2. EC can be practiced at any level of commitment. The book outlines three tracks—full-time, part-time, and occasional EC—emphasizing that any degree of EC is beneficial. Parents can practice as little as once a day or during specific times (like mornings or after naps), and can use diapers as backup whenever needed. This flexibility makes EC adaptable to any lifestyle or family situation.

3. Babies are born with elimination awareness. Newborns naturally resist soiling themselves and give signals before eliminating. By putting babies exclusively in diapers, we train them to ignore these signals and become comfortable eliminating in their clothing, which we must later unteach during conventional toilet training.

4. Observation is the foundation of EC. The process begins with observing when babies typically eliminate—often upon waking, during/after feeding, or during transitions. Through observation, parents learn their baby's unique signals, which may include squirming, fussing, becoming still, or vocalizing in specific ways.

5. Cueing creates two-way communication. Parents make consistent sounds (like "psss" for urination) while holding babies in position to eliminate. Over time, babies associate these sounds with elimination, allowing parents to communicate when it's an appropriate time to release. This establishes a valuable communication channel between parent and child.

6. EC equipment is simple and adaptable. While specialized equipment like small potties, split-crotch pants, and training pants can be helpful, EC can be practiced with minimal gear. Many families use common household items like bowls or containers, and dress babies in easy-access clothing. The emphasis is on practicality rather than purchasing specific products.

7. EC strengthens the parent-child bond. Many parents report deeper intuitive connections with their babies through EC practice. The attentiveness required helps parents become more responsive to other subtle cues their baby gives, fostering trust and reducing frustration for both parent and child. EC provides additional opportunities for one-on-one focused interaction throughout the day.

8. Developmental stages affect EC practice. The book details how EC evolves through different stages—from newborn to mobile baby to toddlerhood. Each stage offers unique opportunities and challenges, with babies taking more initiative as they grow. Temporary "potty pauses" commonly occur during developmental transitions like crawling or walking.

9. EC is practiced worldwide. In many cultures across Africa, Asia, South America, and parts of Europe, babies are traditionally kept aware of elimination rather than trained to use diapers. The book notes that approximately 50% of the world's children are toilet independent by age one, suggesting that extensive diaper use until age 2-3 is the modern anomaly, not early toilet awareness.

10. EC offers environmental and financial benefits. Conventional diapering costs can exceed $3,000 per child and contributes to billions of disposable diapers in landfills annually. Even part-time EC significantly reduces this impact. While some families invest in EC-specific gear, these reusable items typically cost less than years of disposable products.

11. Graduation is individual and often gradual. "Graduation" to toilet independence happens differently for each child, with some achieving miss-free days early in toddlerhood while others follow timelines similar to conventionally trained children. Many EC practitioners report that their children graduate without the power struggles common in conventional toilet training.

12. EC principles can be adapted for special situations. The book provides guidance for applying EC with premature babies, multiples, children with special needs, and older previously-diapered children. The core principles remain the same—observation, communication, and responsiveness—with adjustments for individual needs and development.

30 Questions and Answers

Question (1): What is Elimination Communication (EC) and how does it differ from conventional toilet training?

Elimination Communication is a gentle, natural approach to addressing a baby's elimination needs from birth onward, based on responding to a baby's innate signals and timing patterns rather than relying exclusively on diapers. It's founded on the understanding that babies are born with awareness of their elimination and an instinct not to soil themselves. Through EC, parents learn to recognize when their baby needs to eliminate and hold them over an appropriate receptacle (potty, toilet, sink), while making a cueing sound that the baby learns to associate with elimination.

Unlike conventional toilet training which typically begins when a child is 2-3 years old and focuses on teaching a diaper-dependent child to switch to using the toilet, EC is about maintaining the awareness babies are born with. It's not about "training" but rather communication. EC avoids the double work of first training a baby to use a diaper and then later training them to stop using it. The book emphasizes that EC is not about getting a child potty trained earlier, but about the process of communication and connection with your child, helping them retain their natural bodily awareness from birth.

Question (2): What are the three tracks of EC practice described in the book and how do they differ?

The book introduces three tracks of EC practice: full-time EC, part-time EC, and occasional EC. Full-time EC practitioners typically start soon after birth and aim to provide their baby opportunities to eliminate outside of diapers as much as possible throughout the day and night. The baby is often worn in a sling, kept close to the caregiver, and may be diaper-free early on. Through intensive observation and responsiveness, full-time EC'ers typically catch most pees and all poops, with few misses, and the practice becomes second nature.

Part-time EC involves catching whatever eliminations are practical within the family's schedule and circumstances. Practitioners might focus on EC during specific times of day (like mornings or evenings), or they might choose to catch only bowel movements, which are more predictable. Occasional EC is even more relaxed, possibly catching as little as one pee a day or offering opportunities during convenient times like diaper changes or before bath time. Even with occasional EC, parents make an effort to acknowledge elimination, keeping communication open about the process. The book emphasizes that these tracks aren't rigid categories, and many families fluctuate between approaches depending on their circumstances and the baby's development.

Question (3): How does Christine Gross-Loh describe her personal journey to discovering and implementing EC with her children?

Christine Gross-Loh first heard about EC during her first pregnancy but initially dismissed it as ludicrous despite having witnessed infants being pottied while studying abroad. With her first son, Benjamin, she ignored the newborn spray during diaper changes and stocked her diaper bag with plenty of supplies. Although she became aware of her son's elimination patterns, she didn't consider using EC until her mother bought Benjamin a potty when he was thirteen months old. Despite initial indignation at the idea of "early" potty training, she sat Benjamin on the potty "just for fun" and was astounded when he peed immediately, continuing to do so consistently.

With her second son, Daniel, she began EC at three weeks old but practiced it very part-time due to health issues during his infancy. Sometimes they practiced as little as once a week during the early months, later focusing just on catching poops, and eventually practicing more full-time as he got older. He reached toilet independence at around seventeen months. Gross-Loh emphasizes that even her limited part-time practice still helped Daniel maintain bodily awareness and made for a smoother transition out of diapers. Her story illustrates that EC can be practiced in various ways and intensities, adapting to each family's unique situation and each child's individual development.

Question (4): What are the most common myths and misconceptions about EC addressed in the book?

One major misconception the book addresses is that EC trains the parent rather than the child. Gross-Loh counters that learning a baby's elimination cues is similar to learning hunger or sleep signals—a natural part of responsive parenting. Another myth is that EC would be messy and impractical in Western society with carpeted homes. She explains that families adapt their approach based on their living situation, and the initial learning period is brief, with fewer misses as parent-baby communication improves.

Many people mistakenly believe EC requires constant hovering and obsessive monitoring. The book clarifies that parents quickly recognize patterns and don't need to constantly focus on elimination. Some worry EC forces babies to communicate needs beyond their capabilities, but Gross-Loh explains that by ignoring elimination signals, we're actually asking babies to tune out natural instincts. Other misconceptions include that EC is only for stay-at-home parents, requires exclusive mother involvement, or is overwhelming for busy families. The book counters each of these with practical solutions, emphasizing that EC can be adapted to any lifestyle and practiced to whatever degree works for each family.

Question (5): How do parents typically begin EC with a newborn (0-3 months)?

Parents typically begin EC with a newborn through observation of natural elimination patterns. The book recommends starting by simply noticing when the baby eliminates—perhaps keeping them in loose diapers or on an open prefold to easily observe without disturbing them. Newborns often eliminate upon waking and during or after feeding, providing natural opportunities to observe patterns. Once parents notice their baby starting to eliminate, they can begin "cueing" by making a consistent sound (like "psss" for pee) that the baby will eventually associate with elimination.

For positioning a newborn, the book describes the "in-arms" hold where the baby is cradled securely over a toilet, sink, or bowl. Some parents practice EC during diaper changes or before baths when the diaper is already off. The book emphasizes starting slowly and remaining relaxed about the process, focusing on communication rather than "catching" everything. It also reassures parents that "misses" are normal and provide valuable learning opportunities to better understand the baby's signals. The author encourages parents to start with whatever level of EC feels comfortable, whether that's occasional observation, focusing just on bowel movements, or more frequent opportunities.

Question (6): What are the typical signals babies give when they need to eliminate, and how do these change as they grow?

Newborns often signal the need to eliminate through subtle cues such as squirming, fussing, spitting up, passing gas, or making a sudden change in behavior. They might also shiver, kick their legs, or briefly stop nursing if they're breastfeeding. As babies grow into middle infancy (3-8 months), their signals become more pronounced and may include wiggling, kicking, arching the back when being held, making specific vocalizations, or displaying a blank expression or frown. Some babies begin to show interest in the bathroom or potty, staring at it or playing with a clean potty.

By late infancy and into the toddler stage, babies develop even more explicit ways to communicate their needs. They might sign "potty" if taught baby sign language, crawl or walk toward the bathroom, pull at their diaper, or verbally say "toilet" or other words. Many will directly point to or pat the potty, look down at their legs, or clutch themselves between the legs. The book notes that signals may change frequently throughout development, and some babies may be more obvious with their cues than others. Parents often report periods where signals seem to disappear temporarily, especially during developmental transitions like learning to crawl or walk.

Question (7): What does "cueing" mean in the context of EC, and how is it practiced?

Cueing in EC refers to the practice of making a consistent sound when holding your baby in position to eliminate, which helps them associate that sound with the sensation of releasing bladder or bowels. The most common cue sound for urination is "psss" or a similar gentle hissing sound that resembles water, while for bowel movements parents often make a soft grunting noise that imitates the baby's own sounds. These sounds feel instinctive to many parents and are remarkably consistent across different families and cultures.

To practice cueing, parents hold their baby in an appropriate position (such as the "in-arms" hold over a toilet or potty) while making the cue sound. Initially, parents make the sound when they notice the baby is already eliminating, creating an association between the sound and the action. Over time, babies learn to respond to the cue by releasing their bladder or bowels when they hear it, provided their bladder is full. The book explains that this communication becomes mutually reinforcing - babies learn the cue means it's an appropriate time to eliminate, and parents become more attuned to their baby's natural timing and signals.

Question (8): What types of gear and equipment are helpful for EC practice?

The book describes several categories of helpful EC gear, starting with potties and receptacles. The Baby Bjorn Little Potty is highly recommended for its stability and appropriate size for infants, while the Potty Bowl is a specially shaped container that fits between a parent's thighs for easy infant positioning. For older babies, toilet inserts or reducers allow them to use a regular toilet comfortably. Various clothing options facilitate quick access for pottying, including split-crotch pants with open seams at the crotch, leg warmers like BabyLegs to keep babies warm while bottom-free, and training pants that can absorb small accidents but allow babies to feel wetness.

Other helpful items include waterproof pads (fleece, wool, or PUL material) to protect surfaces during diaper-free time, and baby carriers or slings to keep babies close, making it easier to detect elimination signals. While not required for EC, cloth diapers are mentioned as useful tools even for those primarily using disposables, as they allow both parent and baby to immediately feel when elimination occurs. The book emphasizes that many EC supplies can be improvised from household items, such as using small containers instead of specialized potty bowls, and that beginning EC requires minimal investment in specialized equipment.

Question (9): How do EC practitioners handle nighttime potty needs?

EC practitioners approach nighttime potty needs in various ways depending on their family's sleep priorities and their baby's patterns. Some families choose to diaper their baby at night to prioritize uninterrupted sleep, while others assist with nighttime elimination to help their baby stay dry. The book explains that during sleep, babies produce a hormone called ADH (antidiuretic hormone) that reduces urine production, which is why many babies can stay dry for longer stretches at night than during the day.

For those practicing nighttime EC, typical strategies include keeping a potty near the bed with a cloth diaper inside to absorb pee (eliminating the need to empty it until morning), using waterproof pads under the sheets, and potting the baby during natural wake-ups for feeding or comfort. Some parents report that their babies will stir or signal when they need to eliminate at night, and taking them to potty helps them return to sleep more comfortably. The book emphasizes that there's no right approach to nighttime EC, and many families find their babies naturally develop nighttime dryness whether or not they actively practice EC at night.

Question (10): What challenges might parents face when practicing EC with a mobile baby (8-12 months)?

The primary challenge of EC with a mobile baby is their newfound independence and distraction with exploration. Babies at this age are often so excited about their developing abilities to crawl, cruise, or walk that they may be reluctant to pause for potty breaks. The book describes how mobile babies may ignore their body's signals because they're too engrossed in play, leading to more misses. This stage often coincides with what EC practitioners call "potty pauses" - periods when babies who previously used the potty consistently suddenly seem uninterested or resistant.

The book offers several strategies for this stage, including bringing the potty to where the baby is playing rather than taking them to the bathroom, offering different potties or locations that might interest them more, introducing new toys specifically for potty time, and making potty time more engaging through songs or games. Parents are encouraged to see this stage as part of the baby's normal development rather than a setback, and to try different approaches while remaining relaxed and patient. Sometimes backing off and offering fewer opportunities but responding enthusiastically when the baby shows interest helps work through this challenging phase.

Question (11): How can working parents practice EC effectively?

Working parents can adapt EC to fit their schedules through various approaches. Many working parents practice part-time EC, focusing on morning and evening hours when they're with their baby. The book suggests establishing consistent pottytunities before leaving for work and immediately upon returning home. Some parents report their babies naturally hold elimination while in carriers or car seats, making it easier to offer opportunities at transitions. Preemptive pottying before drop-off and immediately after pickup can prevent wet diapers during commutes.

For childcare situations, some parents find caregivers who are open to EC, particularly those from cultures where early pottying is common. The book includes stories of nannies and daycare providers who successfully implemented EC after seeing its benefits. Even when caregivers aren't practicing EC, many babies adapt to different routines, using the potty with parents and diapers with other caregivers. The book emphasizes that any degree of EC, even just weekends or evenings, helps maintain a baby's awareness and provides connection time between working parents and their children.

Question (12): What are "potty pauses" and how do parents typically handle them?

Potty pauses are periods when a previously receptive baby suddenly seems uninterested in using the potty or begins having consistent misses despite prior success with EC. These pauses often coincide with developmental milestones like crawling, walking, or teething, and are particularly common after the onset of mobility around 8 months. The book explains that these pauses reflect normal development as babies become engrossed in new skills and more independent, not regression or failure.

Parents typically handle potty pauses by making adjustments to their approach. Successful strategies include changing potty locations, trying different potties or positions, introducing new toys specifically for potty time, and sometimes scaling back EC temporarily. Many parents report that backing off pressure and expectations helps resolve pauses more quickly. The book emphasizes maintaining communication about elimination even during pauses, perhaps focusing just on reliable catches like morning pees, and reassures parents that pauses are temporary. Often these challenging periods precede developmental leaps in EC awareness and are followed by renewed interest in using the potty.

Question (13): How does EC work outside the home, such as when traveling or in public places?

EC outside the home requires some adaptability but becomes increasingly manageable with practice. The book suggests traveling with portable equipment like the Potty Bowl, a small receptacle with disposable liners, or a folding toilet seat reducer that fits in a diaper bag. For outdoor settings, standing or squatting positions work well, especially for older babies who can be cued to eliminate into a container, behind a tree, or in grass. Many parents use timing to their advantage, offering pottytunities before leaving home and immediately upon reaching destinations.

Public restrooms present their own challenges, but the book offers solutions like bringing a familiar portable potty, using toilet seat reducers with disposable covers, or holding babies in the classic EC position over public toilets without letting them touch surfaces. Understanding elimination patterns helps parents plan outings during times their baby is less likely to need to go. The book emphasizes that babies often eliminate less frequently when out and about due to natural holding patterns when in car seats, strollers, or carriers, and that even EC-practicing families use diaper backup when necessary for public outings, gradually transitioning to training pants as confidence builds.

Question (14): What are the recommended approaches for practicing EC with a toddler?

With toddlers, EC approaches capitalize on their increasing independence and imitation skills. The book recommends maintaining an open-door bathroom policy so toddlers can observe family members using the toilet, explicitly narrating the process. Teaching sign language for "toilet" helps pre-verbal toddlers communicate their needs, while parents should watch for toddlers' unique signals like running toward the bathroom, looking down at their legs, or clutching themselves. At this stage, the approach shifts toward letting toddlers take more initiative rather than parent-led pottying.

The book cautions against using praise like "good job" when toddlers use the potty, suggesting instead positive acknowledgment that emphasizes how using the potty benefits them. This approach avoids making potty use about external validation. For toddlers new to EC after being exclusively diapered, the book recommends a three-step approach: first providing diaper-free time to reacquaint them with the sensation of elimination, then helping them make associations between elimination and cues, and finally introducing the potty or toilet as the place to go. Flexibility is emphasized, including options like standing positions for boys and offering chances to eliminate outdoors or in different containers if toddlers show resistance to traditional potties.

Question (15): How can parents involve other caregivers, family members, or daycare providers in EC?

Parents can involve other caregivers in EC by first helping them understand that EC is about communication rather than pressure or early training. The book suggests demonstrating EC techniques and explaining the baby's specific signals and patterns. For skeptical caregivers, parents might start by asking them to simply observe when the baby eliminates or to offer pottytunities during natural transitions like diaper changes. Providing the right equipment, such as a familiar potty that stays at the caregiver's location, can facilitate the process.

The book includes success stories of grandparents, fathers, and even daycare providers who initially resisted EC but became enthusiastic after witnessing babies' clear signals and positive responses to pottying. Parents report various arrangements from full EC participation by caregivers to hybrid approaches where babies use diapers with certain caregivers and the potty with others. The book emphasizes that babies are adaptable and can learn different routines with different people. For working parents specifically, the author suggests including EC questions during caregiver interviews and being patient as caregivers develop their own EC relationship with the child.

Question (16): What is "graduation" in EC terms, and when/how does it typically occur?

"Graduation" in EC terms refers to toilet independence—when a child consistently uses the toilet on their own with few or no misses. Unlike conventional toilet training definitions that require complete self-sufficiency (including dressing), EC graduation often occurs while children still need assistance with clothes or getting onto the toilet. The book emphasizes that graduation happens differently for each child, with some achieving miss-free days early in toddlerhood while others may follow timelines similar to conventionally trained children.

The path to graduation is described as highly individual. Some families experience a smooth, gradual transition to independence, while others report that their children suddenly become miss-free after a period of resistance or potty pauses. The book cautions against viewing graduation as a competitive milestone or setting arbitrary deadlines, emphasizing that EC's value lies in the communication journey rather than early toilet independence. Many EC practitioners report that their children graduate without the power struggles common in conventional toilet training, and that the transition often happens so naturally they hardly notice when their child has become fully toilet independent.

Question (17): How can EC be implemented with special situations such as premature babies or multiples?

For premature babies, the book recommends waiting until they reach their adjusted due date or come home from the hospital before beginning EC. Parents can then follow the same principles as with full-term babies, adapting to the baby's developmental readiness rather than chronological age. With twins or multiples, parents often practice EC part-time or occasionally at first, gradually increasing as they become more comfortable with the process. The book emphasizes that even occasional EC helps maintain babies' bodily awareness and suggests pottying multiples individually rather than simultaneously to avoid confusion.

For children with special needs, EC can be particularly beneficial as it provides another communication channel between parent and child. The book cites testimony from a pediatrician who works with children with developmental disabilities, noting that EC can be especially valuable because these children may not follow typical developmental timelines and might not respond to conventional toilet training methods. The approach with all special situations emphasizes flexibility, observation of individual patterns, and adaptation to each child's unique needs and development, with the communication aspect of EC remaining central regardless of when or whether complete toilet independence is achieved.

Question (18): What are the environmental and financial benefits of EC mentioned in the book?

The environmental impact of disposable diapers is significant, with the book citing that 22 billion single-use diapers enter U.S. landfills annually. By reducing diaper usage through EC, parents can substantially decrease this environmental footprint. Even part-time EC makes a difference, as each eliminated diaper change represents one less diaper in a landfill. Some parents practice EC specifically for these environmental benefits, wanting to minimize their impact on the planet while raising their children.

Financially, the book notes that conventional diapering costs can exceed $3,000 per child when accounting for diapers alone, not including wipes and other accessories. By age three, a conventionally diapered child may have gone through approximately 9,000 diaper changes. EC practitioners frequently report significant savings, often using just a fraction of the diapers they would otherwise require. While some parents invest in EC-specific gear like special potties or training pants, these reusable items typically cost less than years of disposable products. The book includes testimonials from parents who started EC for other reasons but came to appreciate the financial savings as an unexpected benefit.

Question (19): How is EC practiced in other cultures around the world?

EC or similar practices are common throughout much of the world, particularly in Africa, Asia, South America, and parts of Europe. The book notes that in countries like China, India, Greenland, and Russia, babies are traditionally held away from the caregiver's body when they need to eliminate, often accompanied by a whistle or hissing sound. These cultures typically don't use diapers extensively, if at all. The practice is so ingrained that internationally adopting parents are sometimes surprised to find their babies already toilet-aware upon arrival.

The book points out that in many cultures, babies are carried close to caregivers' bodies throughout the day, making it easier to detect elimination signals. These caregivers become so attuned to subtle cues that they can anticipate when babies need to eliminate. Statistical evidence cited in the book states that approximately 50% of the world's children are toilet independent by age one. The author observes that it's actually the extensive use of diapers until age 2-3 that's the modern anomaly, not early toilet awareness, and that EC-like practices were common in the United States until disposable diapers became widespread in the 1960s and 1970s.

Question (20): What role does babywearing play in EC, according to the book?

Babywearing facilitates EC by keeping babies in close proximity to caregivers, making it easier to detect subtle elimination signals and timing patterns. The book explains that babies carried in slings or carriers typically develop a rhythm of eliminating when taken out of the carrier rather than while being worn. This natural pattern helps caregivers anticipate when to offer pottytunities, such as immediately after removing baby from a carrier. Additionally, carriers allow parents to sense "phantom pees"—a feeling of warmth against their body that often indicates a baby needs to eliminate, even before the baby has actually gone.

The book describes various carriers suitable for EC, including ring slings, wrap slings, mei-tai carriers, and soft backpacks, noting that each offers different advantages for different stages and situations. While babywearing isn't necessary for successful EC, many practitioners find it naturally complementary. The close physical contact enhances the intuitive communication central to EC, helping parents become more attuned to their baby's needs in general. The book also suggests that carriers can be padded with a cloth diaper during early EC stages, allowing skin-to-skin contact while catching any elimination that might occur unexpectedly.

Question (21): What types of clothing are most conducive to practicing EC?

Clothing that allows quick and easy access for potty opportunities works best for EC. The book specifically mentions split-crotch pants (originating in China) with openings along the crotch seams that appear closed when walking but open when baby squats to eliminate. These are available in various materials including cotton, fleece, wool, and velvet. For keeping legs warm while allowing potty access, the book recommends BabyLegs and similar leg warmers that cover from ankle to thigh, permitting babies to wear just a top and diaper/training pants/underwear below.

The book advises avoiding one-piece outfits with snaps for newborns, as these require complete clothing changes with each diaper change. For older babies and toddlers, elastic-waist pants that can be quickly pulled down are ideal. The book notes that diaper-free babies often need smaller clothing sizes for bottoms, as regular clothes are designed to accommodate bulky diapers. The author reassures parents that "regular clothes" can still be used while EC'ing, especially when going out, but suggests having some EC-friendly options for home use to facilitate quick potty opportunities without the struggle of complicated clothing.

Question (22): How can parents deal with skepticism or criticism from others about EC?

The book suggests several approaches for handling skepticism. First, parents can explain that EC isn't about "training" but about responding to a baby's natural communication, similar to responding to hunger cues. When critics argue EC is training the parent rather than the child, parents can point out that learning any baby's cues is part of responsive parenting. For those concerned about mess or practicality, parents can explain that EC can be practiced with diaper backup and adapted to fit any lifestyle or living situation.

When facing criticism about EC being labor-intensive or a throwback to less progressive times, the book recommends pointing out that conventional diapering actually creates double work: first training a baby to eliminate in diapers, then later training them to stop. Many EC'ers find showing rather than telling most effective—when skeptics witness the gentle, responsive nature of the practice and the baby's evident comfort and participation, misconceptions often dissolve. The book also suggests finding like-minded support through organizations like DiaperFreeBaby or online communities where parents can share experiences and gain confidence in their choices despite outside criticism.

Question (23): What are the most common times babies typically need to eliminate?

According to the book, babies tend to follow predictable elimination patterns that parents can use to time "pottytunities." The most reliable times include: immediately upon awakening from sleep (naps or nighttime), during or after nursing/feeding (especially for bowel movements), and when transitioning between activities like coming out of a carrier or car seat. Many babies also eliminate when their diaper comes off during changes, providing a natural opportunity to offer the potty.

The book notes that babies typically eliminate more frequently in the mornings and less often during afternoons. They also tend not to eliminate while deeply engaged in activities, asleep, or while being carried close to the body. As babies develop, these patterns become more pronounced and predictable. The book emphasizes that while timing is helpful, each baby has individual patterns, and parents generally develop an intuitive sense of their baby's rhythms through observation. This timing-based approach can be especially useful for parents who find it difficult to detect their baby's elimination signals or for caregivers who are new to the baby.

Question (24): How does the author suggest handling cleanups and misses?

The author approaches misses matter-of-factly, emphasizing that they're a normal part of the EC journey. For cleanup preparation, she recommends keeping spray bottles with water, vinegar solution, or natural cleaners at various locations throughout the home, along with cloths or paper towels for quick response. For carpet or textiles, she suggests blotting the area, diluting with water, applying soap or detergent, rubbing well, and rinsing with clean water. The book specifically mentions Bac-Out by Bi-O-Kleen as a favorite natural stain remover among EC families.

For managing misses without stress, the book introduces the "three-miss rule"—after three consecutive misses, put the baby back in a diaper for the rest of the day or session, which alleviates frustration and provides a fresh start later. The author encourages parents to view misses as learning opportunities that provide valuable information about the baby's patterns. She repeatedly emphasizes maintaining a relaxed attitude about misses, pointing out that EC isn't about perfection but communication. The book also notes that many EC practitioners find they actually deal with less mess overall compared to exclusive diapering because poop typically goes directly into potties rather than requiring cleanup from the baby's body and clothes.

Question (25): How do parents balance EC with their busy lives and other children?

The book acknowledges the challenge of balancing EC with busy lives but suggests viewing EC as just another aspect of responsive parenting, similar to feeding or comforting. For multitasking parents, the author recommends planning ahead by offering pottytunities before predictably busy times (like meal preparation) and keeping potties in multiple locations for quick access. Parents are encouraged to use diaper backup without guilt when life gets hectic, remembering that any degree of EC is beneficial for maintaining a baby's awareness.

For families with older children, the book highlights how siblings can actually facilitate EC. Many parents report that older children are remarkably intuitive about their younger siblings' potty needs, often alerting parents when the baby needs to go. Siblings serve as powerful modeling influences, as babies learn by watching others use the toilet. The book includes stories of siblings helping to bring potties, entertaining babies during potty time, or teaching potty signs. The author emphasizes that EC is a family activity that can strengthen relationships between siblings rather than taking away from time with older children, comparing it to the way families accommodate diaper changes or feeding within their daily rhythms.

Question (26): What is the role of intuition in EC practice?

Intuition plays a significant role in EC, with many parents developing what the book calls an "unconscious awareness" of their baby's elimination needs. Parents frequently report just "knowing" when their baby needs to eliminate, sometimes describing it as a gut feeling. The book explains that this intuition develops naturally through close observation and interaction, similar to how parents learn to anticipate their baby's hunger or sleep needs. Some parents experience physical sensations called "phantom pees"—feeling warmth even though the baby hasn't yet eliminated—which often accurately predict imminent need.

The book describes intuition as complementary to timing and signal-based approaches. When explicit signals aren't apparent, parents can rely on this developed sense of their baby's rhythms. The author notes that intuition often becomes stronger over time, allowing parents to tune in to their baby's needs even when physically separated or in another room. This intuitive connection is portrayed as one of the most rewarding aspects of EC, deepening the parent-child bond and communication beyond elimination needs. The book suggests that this intuitive awareness transfers to other aspects of the relationship, helping parents better understand their children's needs and communications in general.

Question (27): How does EC affect the parent-child communication and relationship?

EC fosters a deeper level of communication and trust between parent and child by acknowledging and responding to one of a baby's basic needs. The book includes numerous testimonials from parents who describe feeling more connected to their babies through the practice, with many noting they understand their babies better overall, not just regarding elimination needs. Parents report that EC provides additional opportunities for one-on-one focused interaction throughout the day, especially valuable for toddlers who might otherwise be constantly on the move.

This enhanced communication creates a cycle of trust where babies learn their parents will help meet their needs, which extends beyond elimination. Parents describe EC as another "language" they share with their child before verbal communication develops. The book suggests that the attentiveness required for EC helps parents become more responsive to other subtle cues their baby gives. Many families report that EC reduces fussiness and crying because babies have another way to communicate discomfort. The author frames EC as part of a responsive parenting approach that respects children as capable communicators from birth, laying groundwork for positive communication patterns throughout childhood.

Question (28): What approach does the book recommend regarding praise and reinforcement during EC?

The book specifically cautions against using praise like "good job" or "good boy/girl" during EC, recommending instead acknowledgment and positive reinforcement that focuses on the child's experience rather than external validation. The author explains that by avoiding praise, parents help children understand that using the potty is their own accomplishment rather than something done to please others. This approach aligns with the philosophy that elimination is a natural bodily function like eating or sleeping, which aren't typically praised.

Instead of praise, the book suggests warm acknowledgment of what happened ("You peed in the potty") or expressing how it benefits the child ("It feels good to pee, doesn't it?"). Parents are encouraged to remain enthusiastic and positive about potty use without making it about performance or rewards. Similarly, the book recommends a matter-of-fact approach to misses, avoiding negative reactions that might create anxiety. This balanced approach helps children develop a healthy relationship with their bodily functions while maintaining ownership of the process. The author emphasizes that the goal is for children to use the toilet for their own comfort and well-being, not for external rewards or approval.

Question (29): How can EC principles be applied to older children who have been in diapers?

For older children who have been exclusively diapered, the book recommends a modified EC approach focusing first on helping them regain bodily awareness. This begins with diaper-free time—either completely naked or in training pants—so the child can experience the sensation of eliminating and connect it with the appropriate muscles. Parents should acknowledge elimination when it happens ("You're peeing!") while making a consistent cueing sound to build associations. The book emphasizes patience during this awareness-building phase, as children need time to reconnect with sensations they've been conditioned to ignore.

The next step involves introducing the potty or toilet without pressure. The book notes that older children who have been diapered may show strong attachment to diapers, even asking for one before eliminating. Parents are advised to respect this attachment while continuing to offer alternatives. The author suggests making bathroom time engaging through special toys, books, or activities, emphasizing the bonding aspect rather than performance. For resistant children, parents might try different receptacles (bowls, outdoor spaces) or positions (standing for boys). The book stresses that applying EC principles with older children requires extra patience but can lead to a gentler transition than conventional toilet training methods with their emphasis on rewards and consequences.

Question (30): What support resources does the book recommend for parents practicing EC?

The book highly recommends DiaperFreeBaby, a nonprofit organization founded by Melinda Rothstein and Rachel Milgroom that offers support groups throughout the United States and internationally. These groups provide opportunities to connect with other EC practitioners, see demonstrations with real babies, and view EC-specific gear firsthand. The author, a DiaperFreeBaby Mentor herself, strongly encourages readers to attend local meetings if possible to gain encouragement and practical tips from experienced families.

For online support, the book lists several websites and email groups dedicated to EC, including elimination communication and NaturalInfantHygiene Yahoo groups, the EC forum on Mothering.com, and websites like DiaperFreeBaby.org and Natural-Wisdom.com. It also recommends books by other EC advocates, including Laurie Boucke's "Infant Potty Training" and Ingrid Bauer's "Diaper Free." The resource section includes sources for EC-specific gear like training pants, split-crotch clothing, and specialized potties. The author emphasizes the value of community support throughout the book, noting that EC was traditionally practiced with guidance from experienced family members and that modern parents benefit greatly from rebuilding this community of knowledge and encouragement.

I appreciate you being here.

If you've found the content interesting, useful and maybe even helpful, please consider supporting it through a small paid subscription. While everything here is free, your paid subscription is important as it helps in covering some of the operational costs and supports the continuation of this independent research and journalism work. It also helps keep it free for those that cannot afford to pay.

Please make full use of the Free Libraries.

Unbekoming Interview Library: Great interviews across a spectrum of important topics.

Unbekoming Book Summary Library: Concise summaries of important books.

Stories

I'm always in search of good stories, people with valuable expertise and helpful books. Please don't hesitate to get in touch at unbekoming@outlook.com

For COVID vaccine injury

Consider the FLCCC Post-Vaccine Treatment as a resource.

Baseline Human Health

Watch and share this profound 21-minute video to understand and appreciate what health looks like without vaccination.