18 Comments
User's avatar
Laura Hayes's avatar

Thank you for featuring this elegy, Unbekoming. So many profound thoughts by Wendell Berry. “Nurturers” versus “exploiters”, connection leads to health, the importance of meaningful work that produces something worthwhile, being good stewards of the land and natural resources, people and community over profits and power, and soil as the great connector of lives all resonate loudly.

Russell Schierling's avatar

Incredible! Jaber Crow and Hanna Colter are two of my all-time favorite works of fiction.

@k8_is_awake's avatar

Thank you! Looking into those two specifically🙏🏻 love this post I’m on a Wendell Berry deep dive now

Guillermou's avatar

Thank you for this magnificent tribute to Wendell Berry and for reviving a line of thought that is so necessary in our society.

My diet consists primarily of organic food, sourced locally whenever possible. The truth is that humanity needs to live in an environment where disease does not take hold of our health. We must defend our own well-being, as well as the health of the ecosystems upon which we depend.

Feeding the world does not require a reliance solely on uniform crops, high-tech industrial systems, or agricultural models that are increasingly dependent on large corporations. Instead, we need a diversity of seeds, biodiversity, traditional knowledge, and millions of small- and medium-scale farmers capable of producing food adapted to their specific territories.

The encroachment of agribusiness corporations, the expansion of certain genetically modified (GM) crops, and the reliance on herbicides like glyphosate raise significant questions regarding food sovereignty, environmental health, and the future of biodiversity.

Genetically modified organisms were presented—among other promises—as a solution to global hunger. However, the agricultural model associated with certain GM crops has also fostered a greater dependence on herbicides, particularly glyphosate, with environmental and health consequences that warrant rigorous, independent investigation.

We cannot ignore the potential effects that exposure to these products may have on ecosystems, biodiversity, soil organisms, and human health. Research exists that raises concerns regarding the endocrine system, the gut microbiota, and other biological processes.

Furthermore, we must not overlook the track record of Monsanto—a company linked to controversial products such as DDT, Roundup, and Agent Orange (the latter also manufactured by other firms).

The fundamental question is: what kind of agricultural and food system do we want for future generations?

Defending traditional seeds, organic and regenerative agriculture, agricultural diversity, and food sovereignty is not merely an ideological matter; it is a defense of our natural heritage, our autonomy, and our health. The incidence of chronic diseases in the U.S. has increased over the last 20 years. Glyphosate disrupts the endocrine system, the balance of gut bacteria, and the bioavailability of nutrients; it also damages DNA, among other effects—a process linked to 22 different diseases.

HUMAN HEALTH AND THE HEALTH OF THE PLANET ARE INSEPARABLE.

https://acbio.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Africa_must_ban_glyphosate_now_Aug2019.pdf

Lynn's avatar

"But the concept of health is rooted in the concept of wholeness. To be healthy is to be whole."

Amen.

Thank you for this beautiful essay. I am saving it and forwarding to many I know and love.

Lynn's avatar

Wendell Berry's life, passion, and body of work is a testament to the saying "We are the ones we've been waiting for." Indeed, it is that simple. If we only knew this simple truth.

Antonio Castellaneta's avatar

Michael, what particularly strikes me about Berry's reflections is his rejection of the idea that nature is something separate from us. We cannot separate ourselves from what has made us. I also wonder how we can speak of economic progress without accounting for what is lost in the process. I don't regard technology as an adversary of humanity, but I believe its value should be measured by what it enables us to become, rather than exclusively by the profit it generates.

Mishelle's avatar

This was so excellent, made me realize I don’t know WB well enough at all, and that’s a real shame I must correct asap!

Zoë's avatar

WOW - I'm just in tears. What a great tribute. I've learned a lot and have already been doing some research with the "robots" for now. This all speaks to what I've noticed and seen since childhood and have spent a lifetime trying to get "back" to the land so I may respect her like this and learn to care for myself and a community.

Barbara Charis's avatar

Thanks for introducing me to Wendell Berry...we were born in the same year. He was so right, if we don't get our feet back down on the ground, there will be no earth left! The pie in the sky crusaders promoting technology and space exploits, when the earth is going...makes me really question their ego-driven intelligence. This has been in my mind totally...and will be the topic of my next substack. The question I have sent to financial and technology promoters...Where will you spend your money, when there is no place to spend it?

Ron Panzer's avatar

yes, those of us who have opposed the corrupt dealings of large and powerful corporations know that whenever a movement or organization opposing them is formed, those very corporate interests have a way of injecting themselves into their own opposition so that it is disempowered and given societal approval, and in the end, accomplishing nothing.

That is why Wendell Berry's warning about movements of people is so appropriate. Even in the current times, those heroic physicians and others who spoke out about the poisoning of the people are often sidelined by the controlled opposition who present themselves as the same, but are wolves in sheeps' clothing, and so many adore them, as they are propped up by media that is also co-opted by the powerful.

Any authentic reform comes from the individual lives lived and the choices each one makes, and the Creator of each one of us sees the difference.

fuzzi's avatar

Fantastic. As always. Thank you.

David Kukkee's avatar

I believe Wendell Berry and I would have gotten along just fine. Thank you, Unbekoming, I enjoyed this memorial to a clear thinking man. Without a doubt, he will be missed.

Brad Mills's avatar

Thank you once again. I have located some of these writings, and some of those are now on order. Please continue!

Graham (baba gbb)'s avatar

Berry’s life and work are really something akin to a cosmology of the real world, out of and into which we are all made by our creator and must live together for our brief time here. Blessings to him eternally and to you for sharing this most excellent homage.

al jenkins's avatar

...i hate Monks - - i hate their isolated 'ivory towers', i hate their holier than thou attitudes, i hate their desertion from the field of battle (this struggle Won't bring PERFECTION fellas , so i'm free in my conscious to abandon you) - - consider that Berry did not show us a thing by his Regenerative Farm in Kentucky ( the blessed AMISH have done this for centuries ) - - AND the thing he said could Not be accomplished is happening today , organic produce in every Walmart in America and expanding , plus an aggressive intervention to whole foods , whole milk etc by a political zealot for healthy bodies healthy foods named Bobby Kennedy and this present Administration - - look at the Scars upon the face of Sec Kennedy & upon his Reputation as the price of battle but w victory after victory in behalf of all Americans - - Mr Berry you've left the progress of Human Development to others, bless each & every one of them, you not so much. ........ .......blessings everyone

andy's avatar

“If you build it, they will come,” but if it’s a battleField of Dreams, many of them will go, too, to fertilizer in that field.

For some, that will be their highest & best use. Fertilizer.

For most, it won’t be. Waste.

You’ve got Wendell Berry amish-mashed wrong.

& Kennedy, too.

Allen's avatar
20hEdited

Opening to Berry's brilliant essay, "In Distrust of Movements":

"I have had with my friend Wes Jackson a number of useful conversations about the necessity of getting out of movements—even movements that have seemed necessary and dear to us—when they have lapsed into self-righteousness and self-betrayal, as movements seem almost invariably to do. People in movements too readily learn to deny to others the rights and privileges they demand for themselves.

[...]

They almost always fail to be radical enough, dealing finally in effects rather than causes. Or they deal with single issues or single solutions, as if to assure themselves that they will not be radical enough."

Conclusion:

"My first condition is that this movement should begin by giving up all hope and belief in piecemeal, one-shot solutions. The present scientific quest for odorless hog manure should give us sufficient proof that the specialist is no longer with us."

[...]

"My second condition is that the people in this movement (the MTEWIID) should take full responsibility for themselves as members of the economy. If we are going to teach the economy what it is doing, then we need to learn what we are doing."

[...]

"My third condition is that this movement should content itself to be poor. We need to find cheap solutions, solutions within the reach of everybody, and the availability of a lot of money prevents the discovery of cheap solutions."

Entire essay here:

https://orionmagazine.org/article/in-distrust-of-movements/