15 Comments
User's avatar
Atlandea's avatar

I wrote to Unbekoming regarding the Adequan. I have a 10 year old German Shorthair Pointer.

I had been off on a vacation for 8 days and he was being taken care of by friends in my home. When I got home he couldn't put his right front leg down without severe pain. Interesting timing?

The vet took whole body xrays for $1,000.00 and he was diagnosed with osteoarthitis in both his front knees.

I bought a package of 6 cold laser treatments for $175.00. He is now good as new. Pain killers for only a couple days. No drugs now. I supplement his food with DHEA, and MSM, and mix of glucosamine , mussel etc.

Great Essay. I may print it and send it off the vet.

Guillermou's avatar

Thank you very much for this interesting article and for providing data that invites reflection. I believe it highlights a fairly widespread problem in modern medicine: too many medications focus on alleviating symptoms, rather than necessarily addressing the underlying cause or altering the progression of the disease.

To this, we must add the potential side effects—some of which can be serious—as well as the environmental impact of pharmaceutical waste, which contaminates our water and soil, thereby affecting animals and ecosystems alike.

Both humans and animals require a more preventive approach to medicine—one rooted in healthy nutrition, a less polluted environment, and lifestyle habits that promote well-being.

When a disease arises, priority should be given to treatments that target its root causes and the mechanisms driving its progression, rather than simply suppressing the symptoms.

We need a more preventive and integrative approach to medicine—one that is respectful of the health of humans, animals, and the environment.

In veterinary medicine, there are compelling examples of this approach: for canine osteoarthritis, measures such as adapted exercise, rehabilitation, weight management, and proper nutrition—including the use of omega-3 fatty acids—can help improve mobility and modulate inflammation. For other conditions, therapeutic diets and the care of the microbiome can also play a significant role.

These strategies are incorporated into the international COAST recommendations for canine osteoarthritis. A relevant reference can be found here: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/veterinary-science/articles/10.3389/fvets.2023.1137888/full

Sherri's avatar

Thanks for your input Guillermo. Dr. Judy Morgan also suggests PEAN. I use it for myself and my animals instead of any type of pain medication‘s as it also helps the gut and many other things. I started using it instead of gabapentin on my cats after surgeries and with other issues and there are absolutely no side effects like there are with gabapentin with the vomiting and potential neurological problems? As well as muscular skeletal and the long run.

❤️ Thanks everybody for the awareness

INGRID C DURDEN's avatar

As a first time dog owner, I had no idea about all this. My puppy was injected without me even knowing, the young replacement vet just gave her 2 shots at 8 weeks old. When the old vet returned she said this was way too young. She got several more before surgery. All in her first year. After that, I only allowed the rabies, which is mandatory in our state, first few years the yearly, then I heard about a 3 year one and that is what we had the last 9 years. The vet noticed she had a bit of a limp and suggested injections for arthritis but I refused. She is taking chondroitin and does not seem to be in pain. A bad rash (suggested, allergies?) we worked through thanks to Unbekoming articles and the book. It is now, 5 months later, good as gone, although some spots keep coming back. But they disappear again after treatment. We are now going to work our way to NO vet visits at all. For the rash all they offered was something to stop the itch (90 bucks injections, 70 bucks a month meds)

Neil Pryke's avatar

Dogs are used as experimental animals, anyway...

As well as several other mammalian quadruped species (primates, pigs, rodents...)

So when the same prescribing protocols are used for human therapeutic purposes...

The result is often ultimately trial-and-error...

I note that the product described is used in the USA...but not licensed in the UK...

Is that indicative or significant..?

Baldmichael's avatar

The USA loves its shots. The people are quite insane about them.

NotAMushroom's avatar

Acetyl-D-glucosamine is a naturally occurring psgag that cannot be patented. It is highly effective at quieting inflammation and increasing joint comfort when injected subcutaneously. Luitpold, among others, wanted a patentable product. By chemically altering the naturally occurring molecule, they’ve created a monster. And an expensive one at that.

NSAIDs are not naturally occurring molecules. NSAIDs like firocoxib (a cox-2 inhibitor) are prescribed by many veterinarians to be used daily for the duration of the animal’s life because cox-2 inhibitors are marketed as “safe.” They are not, as evidenced by the human drug Vioxx. COX-2 inhibitors are very toxic (g/i, kidneys, cardiovascular, musculoskeletal) when used chronically

Route of administration is important. Oral administration of psgags is not effective but is very expensive and profitable for the vet and manufacturer. Avoidance of adulterated, manufactured chemicals is prudent. Most importantly, avoid toxic exposures (highly processed foods sourced from rendering facilities) and immune system destroying injections, especially vaccines.

Sherri's avatar

Wow, what a pain to try and find this post again because it’s very important, and it is so common for whatever reason.

I always try and use Dr. Judy Morgan who’s a functional medicine doctor For 30 years large and small.

Fortunately, our veterinarian medical model is captured just like our human one and as well as the FDA and AFCO.

They all dragged their legs and say they haven’t heard anything or there’s no problem while they have a lot of times hundreds even thousands of complaints sitting on addressed.

Please forgive me if I’m wrong.

Another Frontline advocate is saving pets one pet at a time on Facebook. I don’t use Facebook anymore, but it’s a wonderful site where people can write in and share what’s happening with their animals when there’s problems such as the above one, because the wonderful lady who was hosting that site atAS the same thing happened to her, except HER DOG DIED THREE MONTHS AFTER SHE HAD CONTINUOUSLY WROTE AND TALKED TO her vet, HILLS, THE FDA?? AFCO? AND THEY JUST BLEW HER OFF, And drug her feet well her and other people’s pets had already died and were sick? And basically said the same thing for over 3 months or more while animals were dying on Hills prescription diet, which later was found to have had toxic levels of a vitamin or supplement in it.

So grateful this person has spoken out

and that she did her due diligence or research.

By doing that she can be helping hundreds of other pets so their owners do the same because there are many alternatives out there.

She has come to one of the best Substacks to help, obviously❤️

🙏❤️🙏

Thank you so much for sharing this and caring. ❤️

sam's avatar

Tried Adequan on an arthritic older horse. Did absolutely nothing.

Sibylle Gabriel's avatar

In Europe we have a treatment with gold particle for dogs which is now also use for humans.

https://www.petbook.de/hunde/hundegesundheit-hundepflege/goldimplantate-fuer-hunde

Antonio Castellaneta's avatar

I think asking questions about a medication's safety, effectiveness, and long-term effects is important, especially when an animal depends entirely on our decisions. But I also think we need to distinguish between what the available studies actually demonstrate and what we believe might explain a disease. An adverse effect is documented evidence; a proposed connection between vaccination and osteoarthritis still requires convincing evidence of causation. I would be interested in seeing that distinction explored further, because questioning a treatment should help us make better decisions, not lead us to replace one uncertainty with another.

Fager 132's avatar

I tried Adequan for a cat with arthritis and stopped after six months because it did nothing, even combined with gabapentin. He showed no improvement at all. I continued trying to manage his pain with gabapentin and at least he wasn't any worse on that, but the Adequan was pointless.

Barbara Charis's avatar

Years ago, I was discussing how to feed dogs right to keep them healthy without mankind's products.. In the wild, animals eat raw food, but our domesticated animals are being fed cooked products out of cans or bags...malnutrition! No enzymes in heated or processed food. Humans are the same eating processed and cooked food, which has no enzymes (or life force). produces illness. Prevention is the best policy. Mankind's commercial offerings are only beneficial for the provider.

Fager 132's avatar

Commercial canned pet foods are cooked, but they have species-specific nutrients added back in. That's why cats fed dog food will eventually get sick: Dog food doesn't contain the amino acid taurine, which is an absolutely required nutrient for cats. By the time it's weaned a dog or cat produces enough enzymes in its pancreas to digest proteins, fats, and carbohydrates, so unless the animal has pancreatic issues that interfere with enzyme production it won't need supplementation. One of my cats arrived from the breeder with significant GI issues and she's the reason I started feeding raw. Her GI distress resolved within six weeks of being on a "lightly cooked" commercial raw diet. After a year on that I switched her to a fresh raw diet. My unconfirmed belief is that her pancreas wasn't producing enough enzymes for her to efficiently digest her food and that the raw meat, which retains the natural enzymes, gave her pancreas the assist it needed.

Dog and cat breeders who feed commercial canned foods produce animals that are indistinguishable from those on raw meat diets. Breeders invest a lot of time and money in their animals and would not feed commercial diets if it made their animals sick or underperform. Anecdotally, two of my cats are on a fresh raw meat diet that's commercially made with organs and nutrients added. Five eat canned Friskies. One will only rarely have a few bites of canned food and eats Friskies kibble almost exclusively. There's no difference in health, activity levels, dental health, or coat quality between those three groups (although I wouldn't feed kibble at all if the one would eat canned or raw food).

Barbara Charis's avatar

You have put a lot of thought into feeding your animals right...most people don't.. They don't even know how to feed themselves. I try hard to eat as much raw food s possible...and note the last time i got really ill was about thirty years ago, when i started meeting.a new friend for 'coffee and conversation.' I would have several cups of coffee daily and add dairy into it. In a couple months, I wound up sick in bed for a couple weeks. I stopped the dairy and have not had a problem since. Its just something that showed the correlation, between cause & effect. The problem with manufacturers adding species-specific nutrients...is the quality of the additions. The nutrients that manufacturers add to human foods are very questionable.