Author’s note: The paper examined here uses the vocabulary of germ theory and the “immune system” model. Words like antibody, autoimmunity, and immune-mediated disease appear throughout the paper. That language is preserved when quoting the researchers or when reporting their framework. In the author’s analytical voice, the same phenomena are described in different terms: the injection of foreign proteins past the digestive barrier, the sensitization Charles Richet documented in 1901, and the body’s response to that injection. The two registers serve different functions. The paper is being examined. The reader is being addressed.
At 22 weeks of age, the vaccinated beagles had produced serum proteins that bound to ten of the seventeen tissue antigens tested. The antigens tested were canine albumin, canine transferrin, bovine cardiolipin, bovine collagen I, bovine DNA, bovine fibronectin, bovine sphingomyelin, porcine insulin, murine collagen IV, and murine laminin. The tissues from other species were chosen because they share enough structural similarity with the canine versions that a response raised against one is likely to bind the other. Fibronectin and laminin are the clearest cases: nearly identical across mammals. The unvaccinated beagles produced no such response.¹
The fibronectin response was 17.6 times higher in the vaccinated group than in the saline controls. The laminin response was 7.6 times higher. The DNA response was nearly double. Every one of the ten reached statistical significance. The paper reports the numbers in a table on page 739 and does not soften them.
The vaccines were routine. Vanguard-5 CV/L from Pfizer, given at 8, 10, 12, 16 and 20 weeks. Imrab-3 rabies vaccine at 16 weeks. The manufacturer’s schedule. The control group received sterile saline at the same time points. The study was conducted at Purdue University’s School of Veterinary Medicine and published in Advances in Veterinary Medicine in 1999.
Five puppies produced this response. Five saline controls did not.
Related
Essay PDF Download (Free Subscribers)
Audio Deep Dive (Paid Subscribers Only)
Support This Work
The essays are free and will stay free. What paid subscribers get is the library that surrounds them: the full digital book catalogue, audio deep dives, archived, and embedded in each essay, and the Questions for Your Doctor, Before You Consent, and Package Insert series. Platinum Supporters also receive the digital edition of every paperback on the day it’s published.
Whichever tier suits, thank you for being here. If you’d like to become a paid subscriber, upgrade a tier, or gift a subscription to someone who might value the work, the options are below.
The Mechanism the Researchers Identified
The Purdue authors named the cause themselves. Vaccines are grown on animal cell cultures. The cultures require bovine serum to feed the cells. Traces of bovine proteins remain in the finished vaccine. These proteins are injected along with an adjuvant designed to inflame the injection site and heighten the response to whatever is present.
The bovine proteins that survive the manufacturing process include fibronectin, laminin, collagen, and other structural components of extracellular matrix. These proteins are highly conserved between mammalian species. The bovine version and the canine version are structurally similar enough that the response raised against the bovine protein binds to the canine protein.
“The strong response to fibronectin in the vaccinated dogs is most likely the result of the injection of bovine fibronectin contaminants in the vaccine,” the authors wrote.² They tested this by fractionating the fibronectin molecule and showed that the serum proteins bound preferentially to the 30-kDa heparin-binding domain. The 45-kDa collagen-binding domain drew little reactivity.
The response was not random. It was directed at the parts of the bovine molecule that most closely resembled the canine molecule. The paper calls this “an antigen-driven process.”
They also confirmed the escalation pattern. The fibronectin response began after the second injection in three of the five puppies and after the third injection in the other two. It reached maximum levels after the fourth. Each additional dose amplified the response the previous doses had primed. The graph on page 740 shows five lines climbing together across the vaccination schedule.
Nineteen Hundred and One
Charles Richet was a French physiologist working aboard the yacht of Prince Albert I of Monaco in 1901. He was trying to develop a vaccine against the toxin of the Portuguese man-of-war. His method was orthodox. Inject a small dose of the toxin. Wait for the animal to recover. Inject a second small dose and check for protection.
The dogs did not develop protection. They developed the opposite. The second injection, weeks after the first, killed them quickly. A dose too small to harm a naive animal was fatal to a sensitized one. Richet named the phenomenon anaphylaxis, from the Greek ana (against) and phylaxis (protection). The word was chosen precisely. He had produced the inverse of what vaccination was supposed to achieve.³
He spent the next decade demonstrating that the effect was not specific to man-of-war toxin. Injection of egg proteins produced it. Injection of milk proteins produced it. Injection of meat proteins produced it. He tested it in dogs, cats, rabbits, horses, and frogs. The mechanism was universal to all animals he tested. What mattered was the route of exposure. Proteins introduced through the digestive tract were processed normally. The same proteins introduced by needle produced escalating sensitization on repeat exposure.⁴
Richet then identified cross-reactivity between related proteins. Milk from different animals, injected into a sensitized dog, produced similar reactions. The body’s response was not exclusively to the exact molecule that had done the sensitizing. It responded to structurally similar molecules from related species. Richet called these “allied protein groups.”⁵ The observation would reappear in the Purdue beagles ninety-eight years later.
He won the 1913 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for this work. In his acceptance lecture he identified three outcomes of vaccination: unchanged sensitivity, diminished sensitivity (habituation), and heightened sensitivity (anaphylaxis). The heightened response was the one his experiments had produced, and he named it as one of the ordinary possibilities of any injection, not an anomaly.⁶
Read the Purdue paper next to Richet’s Nobel lecture. Injection of foreign proteins. Repeat exposure on a schedule of weeks. Cross-reactivity between the injected proteins and structurally similar host proteins. Escalating response with each dose. The beagles produced the mechanism Richet described. Nothing in the veterinary paper contradicts anything in the 1913 Nobel lecture. Nothing in the 1913 Nobel lecture would have predicted anything other than what the beagles produced.
Richet’s name does not appear in the Purdue paper. The word “anaphylaxis” does not appear. The word “sensitization” does not appear. What the paper calls “vaccine-induced autoimmunity” is what Richet, ninety-eight years earlier, called anaphylaxis.
What the Word Hides
The word “autoimmunity” carries a specific implication. It places the fault inside the animal. The body has malfunctioned. The body has failed to distinguish self from non-self. The body is attacking itself.
This framing serves a purpose. It hides the injection. If the body is at fault, then whatever was injected is not implicated. The animal’s own defective machinery becomes the explanation. The manufacturer, the schedule, the adjuvant, the bovine contamination, all recede into background conditions that merely revealed a pre-existing susceptibility.
The word does not stand alone. It sits inside a set of three concepts that hold each other up: the “immune system” that supposedly recognizes friend from foe, the “antibodies” that supposedly execute the recognition, and the “autoimmunity” that supposedly explains what happens when the recognition fails. Take any one of them apart and the other two lose their footing. That is why Purdue can document sensitization from injection in five puppies and still describe the outcome using the vocabulary of self-attack. The vocabulary is the entire structure.
The Purdue findings do not support this reading. The vaccinated puppies produced the response. The unvaccinated puppies did not. Both groups were beagles from the same litters, housed in the same facility, fed the same food. The variable that produced the response was not the animal. The variable was the injection.
Richet named the process correctly. The body was responding to proteins that had bypassed the modifying route of the digestive system.⁷ The digestive tract exists precisely to break foreign proteins into constituent parts before they enter circulation. The stomach’s acid, the pancreatic enzymes, the intestinal wall’s selectivity, all of this machinery is dedicated to ensuring that the proteins reaching the bloodstream have been reduced to amino acids and small peptides no longer recognizable as foreign.
Injection bypasses this. A needle deposits intact foreign proteins directly into tissue, past every barrier the body has to prevent exactly this. The proteins that Richet injected into dogs would have caused no reaction had the dogs eaten them. The proteins that Purdue’s vaccine deposited into puppies caused a response that eating those proteins would not have produced.
The response medicine calls autoimmune is not that. It is directed at foreign material. That foreign material shares structural features with the body’s own tissues. Fibronectin is fibronectin whether it comes from a cow or a dog. The response binds to the body’s own tissues as an inevitable consequence of what was injected.
The “auto” in “autoimmunity” is the deflection. The body did not misfire. The body did what any body does when foreign proteins are injected past the barriers that would otherwise keep them out. What Purdue documented is not the body attacking itself. It is the body responding to injection, exactly as Richet had described a century earlier, and doing so with escalating intensity as the injections continued.
What They Said, What They Did Not Say
The Purdue authors observed all of this. They named the mechanism. They identified bovine cell-culture proteins as the cross-reactive source. They confirmed the escalation pattern across the schedule. They noted that the phenomenon was not confined to one brand or one vaccine. A follow-up study in the same laboratory found the same response in puppies given only the multivalent vaccine, and in puppies given only the rabies vaccine.⁸ The mechanism was intrinsic to the manufacturing process, not an artifact of one product.
Then they wrote this sentence: “Not vaccinating dogs is not a viable option, because the benefits of vaccination clearly outweigh the still uncertain risks of immune-mediated disease.”⁹
The word to notice is “uncertain.” The risks are called uncertain in the same paper that documents the vaccinated puppies producing serum proteins reactive with DNA, with insulin, with connective tissue. What makes the risks uncertain, in the authors’ own words?
The paper answers this on the page before the conclusion. “The pathogenic significance of these autoantibodies is presently uncertain. We did not find any evidence of autoimmune disease in the vaccinated dogs, but the study was terminated when the dogs were 22 weeks of age, well before autoimmune diseases usually become clinically apparent.”¹⁰
They stopped the study before the damage would have shown. Then they cited the absence of what they did not look for as reason to continue.
Consider what an honest continuation would have required. Follow the five vaccinated beagles and the five controls for their natural lives. Biopsy tissue at intervals. Test cognitive function, joint mobility, endocrine function, coat and skin condition. Necropsy at death. Compare rates of the specific chronic conditions the paper names, in its own terms: immune-mediated hemolytic anemia, thyroiditis, glomerulopathy, connective tissue disease.
This study was never done. The five vaccinated puppies were killed at 22 weeks. Their tissues were fixed in 10 percent buffered formalin. The paper is what remains.
The authors acknowledge the constraint themselves. “For practical and economic reasons, only a small number of dogs can be followed in an experimental study, and clinical autoimmune disease may, therefore, never be observed.”¹¹ The framing is that the clinical disease is elusive because studies are small. The alternative framing, that studies are terminated before the disease has time to appear and that this termination is not accidental, is not considered.
The authors close by suggesting that future vaccines eliminate bovine contaminants, perhaps by using naked DNA vaccines free of serum components. They cite a 1997 mouse study whose authors reported that DNA vaccines did not induce or accelerate what the field labels autoimmune disease.¹² The proposed solution was to change the manufacturing platform. The mechanism they had documented, sensitization by injection of foreign material past the digestive barrier, was not what they proposed to address.
The Species Bridge
The Purdue beagles received five doses of Vanguard-5 and one dose of rabies vaccine between 8 and 20 weeks of age. Six injections in three months. Ten of seventeen tissue antigens tested produced elevated responses, with the target tissues drawn from proteins that are structurally near-identical to the beagles’ own.
A child on the current U.S. schedule receives dozens of vaccine doses between birth and 18 years, with the highest concentration in the first two years of life. The exact count depends on how combination products are tallied, but the figure is above 50 by any method of counting.¹³ Most of those doses are manufactured on cell cultures that require animal-derived growth medium. All contain adjuvants or other pharmacologically active ingredients chosen to amplify the response. All bypass the digestive barrier that would ordinarily process foreign proteins into constituent amino acids.
The Purdue mechanism does not become inapplicable when the animal is human. Fibronectin is conserved across mammals. So is laminin, collagen, cardiolipin. The bovine contaminants in a childhood vaccine cross-react with human tissues by the same principle they cross-react with canine tissues. If anything, the human schedule provides more injections, over more years, with more products, than any veterinary schedule.
The paper does not extend its findings to humans. Its authors would not have kept their positions if it had. But the mechanism they documented is not species-specific. It is a property of the manufacturing process. Cell cultures. Bovine serum. Residual proteins. Adjuvants. Injection past the barrier. Cross-reactivity with conserved host tissues. Escalation with repeat exposure.
The rates of what medicine now calls autoimmune conditions in children have risen in step with the expansion of the childhood schedule.¹⁴ Type 1 diabetes, juvenile arthritis, pediatric multiple sclerosis, thyroid conditions, allergies, food anaphylaxis, atopic dermatitis, asthma. The Purdue paper describes, in a small experimental model with clean controls, the mechanism by which this would occur. The paper’s own authors could not follow the mechanism to that conclusion. The reader is under no such constraint.
The document exists. The numbers are on the page. Five puppies. Ten tissues. The mechanism named in 1901. The Nobel Prize awarded in 1913. The confirmation in beagles in 1999. And every child on every schedule since.
How to Explain It to a Six-Year-Old
Imagine a very careful gatekeeper who stands at the front door of a big house. Everything that comes into the house has to go through the gatekeeper. The gatekeeper’s job is to check every visitor, ask what they are made of, and if the visitor is food or drink, break it down into tiny harmless pieces before letting those pieces enter the house. This gatekeeper has been at the door for a very long time. He knows exactly what to do.
Now imagine that instead of coming through the front door, some visitors are shot through the wall of the house with a slingshot. They land in the middle of the living room, whole and untouched, without ever meeting the gatekeeper. The people who live in the house have never seen visitors arrive this way before. They get confused. They start trying to get rid of everything in the living room that looks like the visitors, even the furniture, because the furniture happens to be made of some of the same materials the visitors are made of.
This is what happens when things are injected into a body. The stomach is the gatekeeper. The needle is the slingshot. And what gets damaged, along with the visitors, are the parts of the body itself that look most like the visitors: the connective tissues, the DNA, the things that hold cells together. The scientists at Purdue University did this experiment on five puppies in 1999 and wrote down exactly what happened. Then they said the puppies were fine and everyone should keep using the slingshot.
The puppies were not fine. The scientists just stopped watching before the trouble showed up. That is the story of a lot of what happens in medicine. The trouble takes a long time to appear, and by then no one is looking for the slingshot anymore. They are looking for something to blame inside the house.
In Print
The Unbekoming library is available in paperback, printed to order through Lulu and shipped worldwide. The shelf begins with the paradigm question underneath everything else — No Virus, the isolation problem, the collapse of virology’s foundational claims, and a disease-by-disease reappraisal — and moves through the suppressed compounds mainstream medicine set aside: The DMSO Book, Chlorine Dioxide: The Forbidden Remedy, The Iodine Book, and The Hydrogen Peroxide Book. Two more recover what’s still on the kitchen shelf: Baking Soda and The Castor Oil Book. Two more recover the minerals modern soil, water, and processing quietly stripped from the diet: The Magnesium Handbook and The Boron Book. Sitting alongside these is No Contagion, co-authored with Jamie Andrews — the case against germ theory itself, catalogued through 258 failed contagion experiments.
The critique books cover what medicine, dentistry, psychiatry, and veterinary practice have become. The Unvaccinated treats the completely unvaccinated as a comparison group across twenty chapters and five appendices. Medicalized Motherhood follows a woman through 123 documented interventions from teenage pill to postpartum discharge. Drilling for Profit treats cavities, gum disease, and crooked teeth as the dietary problem they are. What Your Vet Can’t Tell You applies the same critique to pets. Escape from Psychiatry documents the fabrication of the DSM and the specific damage of every major psychiatric drug class. The Vitamin K Injection covers what happens in the first hours of a newborn’s life.
The full shelf is at lulu.com/spotlight/unbekoming. A physical book reaches the person a Substack post never will — the skeptical relative, the friend who won’t click a link but might open a book, the visitor whose eye lands on a coffee table. Buy one to keep, and one to give away.
References
Hogenesch H, Azcona-Olivera J, Scott-Moncrieff C, Snyder PW, Glickman LT. “Vaccine-Induced Autoimmunity in the Dog.” Advances in Veterinary Medicine Vol. 41, 1999, pp. 733-747. Table I, p. 739.
Ibid., p. 743.
Fraser H. The Peanut Allergy Epidemic. Skyhorse Publishing, 2011. Chapter on Richet, describing the 1901 experiments aboard the yacht of Prince Albert I of Monaco.
Ibid. Richet’s subsequent experiments on cats, rabbits, horses, and frogs, demonstrating universality of the mechanism across animal species.
Ibid. Richet’s identification of cross-reactivity between “allied protein groups,” including cross-reaction of milk from different animal species in sensitized dogs.
Richet C. “Anaphylaxis.” Nobel Lecture, December 11, 1913. Available at the Nobel Prize archive. The three outcomes of vaccination described in this lecture: unchanged sensitivity, diminished sensitivity (habituation), and heightened sensitivity (anaphylaxis).
Ibid. Richet’s finding that anaphylaxis results from proteins entering the bloodstream without having been modified by the digestive system.
Hogenesch et al., 1999, p. 741. “In a follow-up study, we have observed similar autoimmune phenomena in dogs immunized with the multivalent vaccine only and in dogs immunized with the rabies vaccine only (unpublished observations).”
Ibid., p. 745.
Ibid., p. 740.
Ibid., p. 741.
Mor G, Singla M, Steinberg AD, Hoffman SL, Okuda K, Klinman DM. “Do DNA vaccines induce autoimmune disease?” Human Gene Therapy 8, 1997, pp. 293-300. Cited in Hogenesch et al. p. 745.
CDC Recommended Immunization Schedule for Children and Adolescents, current edition. The individual dose count varies by year, by combination product, and by counting method. The floor of any reasonable count is above 50 doses across the 0-18 age range, with the majority administered before age six. The CDC schedule is publicly available and can be counted by the reader.
Classen JB. “Review of vaccine-induced immune overload and the resulting epidemics of type 1 diabetes and metabolic syndrome, emphasis on explaining the recent accelerations in the risk of prediabetes and other immune-mediated diseases.” Journal of Molecular and Genetic Medicine 2014; S1:025. Cited in Miller NZ, Miller’s Review of Critical Vaccine Studies, entry 261. Documents the association between the expansion of the childhood vaccine schedule and the rise in type 1 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, and other conditions the field labels autoimmune.







Thank you for revealing one of the significant harms that vaccines can cause. We need to compose a requiem for vaccines and for all those who have promoted them. This should be a chronicle of a death foretold. Today, in the face of such widespread apathy, it is time to play a requiem—and to dance, so as not to weep—over the crimes committed against humanity.
The relationship between vaccines and autoimmune diseases demands complete transparency. Scientific literature has documented autoimmune conditions or immune-mediated reactions following various vaccinations—not just those for COVID-19:
• MMR (measles, mumps, and rubella): immune thrombocytopenic purpura and arthritis.
• Hepatitis B: immune thrombocytopenia, vasculitis, and cases of lupus and thyroiditis.
• Influenza (flu): Guillain-Barré syndrome and cases of vasculitis.
• Polio: cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome.
• Tetanus and diphtheria: documented cases of autoimmune manifestations.
• HPV: potential links to thyroiditis and other immunological diseases have been investigated.
• COVID-19 (Pfizer, Moderna, and AstraZeneca): cases of autoimmune hepatitis, vasculitis, glomerulonephritis, and immune thrombocytopenia.
Mechanisms that warrant further investigation include molecular mimicry, cross-reactivity, and the loss of IMMUNOLOGICAL TOLERANCE. Vaccine safety must be evaluated through independent studies, long-term monitoring, and full transparency regarding adverse effects. 1. General review of vaccines and autoimmunity:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5607155/
2. Review of autoimmune manifestations following viral vaccinations:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15917108/
3. Meta-analysis on vaccination and autoimmune diseases (2021):
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8402438/
4. Hepatitis B and autoimmune diseases:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30100071/
5. HPV vaccine and autoimmune diseases:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31876615/
6. A comprehensive data compilation by STEVE KIRSCH on COVID-19 vaccine-related harms: https://kirschsubstack.com/p/vaccine-adverse-reaction-articles?utm_source=publication-search
Richet belonged to the “elite”—an elite deeply preoccupied with the issue of eugenics. He won the Nobel Prize for his discovery regarding the consequences of repeatedly injecting proteins—and ever since then, vaccines have contained all sorts of proteins…
I strongly suspect that the reason he won that prize was not nearly as “noble” as most people think…